Half Baked Harvest's Spicy Chicken Paprikash {Paprikash #1}

I recently ordered a copy of Half Baked Harvest's Quick & Cozy and I've been having a good time trying the recipes! The first one I made was her Baked Buffalo Chicken Tenders and those were amazing. Then last week I shared her Double Baked Beef Taquitos and those turned out great. This week I'm trying her Spicy Chicken Paprikash. 

For those of you who've never heard of Chicken Paprikash, it is a Hungarian dish that came to America in the early 1900's. Paprikash is a VERY popular dish in Cleveland, Ohio where I'm from. In fact, I believe Tieghan Gerard of Half Baked Harvest is also from the Cleveland area and I'd venture to say that's why she has a recipe for it in her book! It is absolutely delicious and comforting and every single time I go back home I do my best to eat paprikash at least once (and pierogi, but that's another post altogether)!

There are A LOT of ways to make Chicken Paprikash and everyone's version is different! Most versions are chicken in a paprika-heavy cream sauce based on sour cream, or a mixture of sour cream and heavy cream, served over thick dumpling-like noodles or even egg noodles. Everyone has their favorite version!

I have never made Chicken Paprikash before, so I'm going to experiment with several different versions until I find the one that speaks to me. This version is in fact creamy, comforting, and delicious but differs from the traditional Chicken Paprikash because it has quite a bit of tomato paste and 1 full teaspoon of cayenne. The heat of the cayenne is tempered by the addition of sour cream and in my case, heavy cream, and when served over pasta it is not overly spicy, but you do taste the cayenne. 

All in all, this is a delicious version and one that I think everyone would enjoy, but is it THE CHICKEN PAPRIKASH recipe for me? No. I am looking for a more traditional version that is paprika forward and perhaps served with the traditional dumpling-type noodle. 

Chef Michael Symon, also from the Cleveland area has a recipe that I will be trying next! Stay tuned for my next Chicken Paprikash adventure! 

Spicy Chicken Paprikash

Adapted from Half Baked Harvest's Quick & Cozy

by Tieghan Gerard

Serves 4-6 

2 pounds boneless, skinless, chicken thighs or breasts*

salt and pepper

2 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil

4 tablespoons butter

2 tablespoons all-purpose flour

1 large yellow onion, chopped

3 garlic cloves, chopped

2 tablespoons smoked paprika

1 tablespoon sweet paprika

1 teaspoon cayenne pepper

1/3 cup tomato paste

3/4 cup sour cream/heavy cream*

soft pretzels, noodles, dumplings, for serving*

Notes: Oftentimes when a recipe is a saucy type chicken dish and calls for the chicken to be cooked in a skillet and then added to a sauce I will change the method of cooking the chicken. For example, I find that this method leads to the chicken becoming tough and overcooked so instead I will place the chicken in a crockpot on high for 3-4 hours with about 1/2 cup water, salt and pepper. This method allows the chicken to cook through and be very tender, falling apart into nice chunks. My family likes this method best, but if you prefer to cook your chicken on the skillet, go right ahead!

In addition to changing the method of cooking the chicken, I also prefer my paprikash made with a combination of sour cream and heavy cream so I went half sour cream and half heavy cream. And lastly, Half Baked Harvest suggests serving the paprikash with pretzels and I'm sure that's good, but we served our paprikash, like always, with noodles.

To Cook The Chicken: Season the chicken all over with salt and pepper. In a large skillet over medium-high heat, heat the olive oil. When the oil is shimmering, add the chicken and cook, turning once, until it is golden brown, about 4 minutes per side. Transfer the chicken to a plate. (Alternatively, cook the chicken in the crockpot per my instructions above).

To Make The Dish/Sauce: To the same skillet as the chicken over medium heat (or in a new skillet if you cooked the chicken in a crockpot), add the butter, the flour, and the onion. Cook, stirring, until the onion is soft and just beginning to brown, about 5 minutes. Add the garlic, smoked paprika, sweet paprika, and cayenne and cook, stirring, until very fragrant, about 30 seconds. Add the tomato paste, and cook, stirring, 1 minute more. Add 2 cups of water, stirring to form a sauce. 

Return the chicken to the skillet, along with any collected juices. Reduce the heat to low, cover, and simmer gently until the meat is cooked through, 8 to 10 minutes. Stir in the sour cream/heavy cream and the remaining 1 tablespoons butter to incorporate. Taste and add more salt and pepper as needed. Serve family style.  

Pretty Pasta @ IHCC!